It’s mid-November, which implies we’re already approaching the summit of 2024, earlier than you realize it we’ll collectively zip up our jerseys and descend into 2025.
Within the meantime, I discover myself wanting over my shoulder on the yr we’re abandoning and the bikes which have carried me by means of it. So which ones could be the “Bike Of The 12 months?” The place would I even start? Seeking a rubric, I turned to the mainstream biking media:

Listed below are the most effective highway bikes in numerous classes, although as you may see they’re all just about the identical bike:

However wait, there’s extra!

That’s some finely-sliced categorization:

I’m wondering if in the future somebody will determine find out how to make a highway bike that mixes a lot of the above attributes–you realize, one climbs effectively and sprints effectively and is made from metallic and can also be comfy over longer distances.
Nah, it’ll by no means occur.
Oh, wait, sorry, I overlooked extra highway bike classes:

“Greatest efficiency highway?” Is efficiency not an inexpensive expectation with the others? And why does “Italian” get its personal class? It’s 2024! Other than the names, there’s nothing inherently particular about Italian highway bikes anymore. To paraphrase the 4 Questions, why is an Italian bike totally different from all different bikes? Take into account Bianchi, which in 2024 is de facto nothing greater than a colour:

And what about gravel bikes?

At the least there’s not a class for “Greatest Italian Gravel bike.”
Oh, wait, sure there’s:

“I’m out there for an Italian gravel bike” is a phrase you hear solely barely extra usually than “I’m on the lookout for a Saudi Arabian microbrew.” And when the hell did cyclocross get folded into gravel?!? That’s simply insulting. Cyclocross bikes are your entire motive gravel bikes exist. Individuals generally say that gravel bikes are simply ’90s mountain bikes, however they’re actually simply cyclocross bikes that bought dumbed down with disc brakes. However now in fact the cyclocross bikes have disc brakes too, so it’s all principally meaningless.
And I’m not even going to handle mountain bikes, as a result of I don’t think about these bikes anymore:

I’m sorry, the place’s the “regular bike with out a bunch of shit on it” class? That is simply miserable. In the event you’re going to divide mountain bikes into eleven (!) totally different classes (sure, eleven, considered one of them bought lower off within the screenshot) and also you’re not going embody a Jones in any considered one of them, then I’ve no selection however to utterly disregard your entire enterprise.
As for BSNYC/RTMS/Tan Tenovo Enterprises, Ltd. Bike of the 12 months for 2024, at this level I’d slim it down to a few finalists. I’m not saying they’re the “greatest,” however they’re the bikes which have most captured my creativeness and driving time over the previous yr. (They’re additionally the bikes which have come to me most lately, which can have one thing to do with it.) Right here they’re:
Greatest Highway Bike That’s Additionally a Gravel Bike That’s A Singlespeed However You Can Additionally Set It Up As A Double Or A Triple And Additionally It’s Actually Comfy And It’s Metal And It Has Lugs

I’m definitely not saying it’s important to be outdated to like this bike, however I’m saying that is the right bike for the getting older singlespeeder. Certain, I suppose placing a triple crank in your singlespeed is just a little like placing a bunch of handrails within the lavatory. However what’s cooler? Sustaining these “clear strains?” Or with the ability to get off the bathroom?
Greatest Over-The-Prime Early 21th Century Highway Bike From A “Boutique” Model That’s Actually Simply One other Bike From A Enormous Bike Firm

Whereas I embrace and espouse the traditional metal ethos, as a recovering roadie of a sure age, there’s an plain pleasure in driving the unique bikes that had been effectively past your attain if you had been in your “prime.” It looks like I’ve lastly arrived–20 years later, and at a spot the place no one else desires to be anymore, however higher late than by no means, proper?
Greatest Bike I All the time Dismissed As A Rolling Joke However Is Really Surprisingly Enjoyable And Attention-grabbing

I’m nonetheless ready for Outdoors to publish my newest column wherein I share what I realized from one of many Trek engineers who designed this factor. (I actually ought to begin a weblog the place I can publish stuff each time I need.) However what I’ll say in regards to the Y-Ferl is that, whereas superficially it’s the antithesis of every thing I stand for, additionally it is one of many few bikes that takes true benefit of The Crabon, and for that it has earned my respect. The LeMond is half-crabon, however other than being just a little lighter and looking out cool (should you’re into that kind of factor) there’s actually no motive for the crabon–and even the titanium for that matter, and I think I’d take pleasure in driving considered one of its metal contemporaries simply as a lot. The Y-Foil nevertheless makes use of crabon to create a really distinctive body that might be kind of unimaginable in every other materials and nets the rider not solely aero advantages however a refined suspension impact that I have to admit is moderately enchanting. In fact you will get a lot the identical impact from a pair of higher-volume tires, and nowadays I don’t trip practically quick sufficient to understand any of the aero advantages, however within the context of a late-90s race bike I give Trek credit score for pulling off what it got down to do, and it’s a enjoyable bike to trip simply so long as you’re ready to simply accept the power to hold just one water bottle, in addition to the truth that if it’s even just a little moist out that water bottle will probably be completely lined in highway grit as a result of lack of a seat tube.
So which is able to win? I dunno, however I’m going to go out for a trip on considered one of them now, which is able to hopefully convey me nearer to a last determination.