Why trading Jazz Chisholm Jr. would make zero sense for the Yankees

The underside line: Jazz Chisholm Jr. is a star

Arguably a top-three second baseman in MLB, Chisholm is among the finest middle-infield abilities within the sport each offensively and defensively. A very powerful half about him, although, is that he desires to be a Yankee.

„I do not wish to depart New York,“ Chisholm advised The Athletic. „For those who’ve ever performed right here, you’d by no means wish to depart.“

His versatility within the subject has paid dividends for New York, because it has been in a position to make the most of him as a top quality third baseman and second baseman, posting 5 outs above common in 2025. Moreover, he nonetheless possesses the power to play a powerful heart subject, a place the place he developed his expertise throughout his time with the Miami Marlins. 

On the dish, Chisholm was a lightning rod for the Bombers this previous season, slashing .242/.332/.481 en path to posting his first 30-30 season with 31 homers and 31 stolen bases. Though this previous season noticed him go into occasional slumps and streaky hitting, his affect was undoubtedly felt all throughout the sector.

Eliminating a participant of Chisholm’s athleticism and impact on a baseball crew, paired with the truth that he expressed heavy curiosity in staying with the Yankees long-term, merely wouldn’t make sense for New York.

If the Yankees did commerce Jazz Chisholm Jr., who would they get?

Yankees basic supervisor Brian Cashman just lately stated that he was „open-minded“ about buying and selling the 27-year-old if it might bolster their pitching workers.

With pitchers resembling Gerrit Cole, Carlos Rodon and Clarke Schmidt all anticipated to overlook Opening Day, the Bombers would possibly look to commerce for starters resembling Freddy Peralta, Sandy Alcantara or MacKenzie Gore. Whereas Peralta is extra alongside the strains of Chisholm’s worth, it would not be shocking to see him in a commerce for a package deal of gamers from the Washington Nationals, together with Gore and others.

Whereas it might fulfill the need of some pitching assist because the rotation recovers through the spring, opening up one other gap within the infield that was plugged so completely by Chisholm could be damning for the Yankees down the stretch as soon as the pitching workers is wholesome once more.

Rumors of Chisholm getting moved from the Yankees are puzzling, to say the least. It is not daily {that a} crew can land an athletic and impactful participant like Chisholm who brazenly admits that he desires to stick with the crew.

As a probable perennial 30-30 participant who can take over a sport on protection and offense, New York ought to be seeking to lock up Chisholm on a long-term deal, not commerce him away. On the finish of the day, this might boil right down to inner points, be a chess transfer for contract negotiations or simply be a passing offseason rumor, however one factor is for certain: Chisholm’s future within the Bronx is something however sure.