The 2026 Replacement-Level Killers: Shortstop & Third Base

At this time, it’s one other Killers two-fer, overlaying the left aspect of the infield. Whereas nonetheless specializing in groups that meet the unfastened definition of a contender (Playoff Odds of a minimum of 10%, a criterion that 22 of the 30 groups meet) and which have gotten about 0.6 WAR or much less out of a place so far (which prorates to 1.0 WAR over a full season), I’ve additionally integrated our Depth Charts’ rest-of-season WAR projections into the equation for an extra perspective. Which will recommend that a few of these groups will clear the bar by a big margin, besides, I’ve included them right here as a result of their efficiency at that spot deserves a more in-depth a glance. All statistics are via July 12.

Crimson Sox

4 and a half seasons into his six-year, $140 million deal, Trevor Story’s Crimson Sox tenure has been a catastrophe, as accidents have restricted him to 361 video games — lower than 49% of these performed by the staff throughout that span — and 6.1 WAR. Final season was his first time exceeding 94 video games with Boston. Hampered since spring coaching by what had beforehand been characterised with no consideration groin harm, he hit .206/.244/.303 (46 wRC+) with -0.5 WAR in 41 video games earlier than present process surgical procedure to restore a sports activities hernia in late Might. In early June, he relayed the expectation of an eight-to-12-week absence, bracketing his return between proper after the All-Star break and mid-August. As of June 28, he was partaking in full baseball actions, so the hope is he can start a rehab task quickly, and a minimum of approximate his typical league-average-offense-with-plus-defense kind as soon as he returns.

That may’t come a second too quickly, as a result of Boston’s infield has been notably depleted by accidents. Each Marcelo Mayer, who moved over from second base to shortstop when Story went down, and Isiah Kiner-Falefa, who did the majority of the second base work after that shift, have been sidelined by stress reactions of their left ulnas, and neither has a transparent timeline for return. Mayer has hit simply .220/.282/.312 (63 wRC+), whereas Kiner-Falefa has hit .277/.344/.361 (97 wRC+). Tsung-Che Cheng, a lefty-swinging 24-year-old rookie from Taiwan, has been sharing the job with righty Andruw Monasterio since Meyer went down. Each have been moderately productive in the course of the 14-2 surge that has carried the Crimson Sox (46-48) again into competition, however regression looms simply across the nook, and for all of his harm woes, Story’s ceiling remains to be a lot greater.

Phillies

Through the extremely entertaining Dave Dombrowski period, the Phillies have positioned greater than their fair proportion of gamers on my Killers lists, typically because of the staff’s laissez-faire angle towards protection. Nonetheless, until you learn my current have a look at the worst defenses amongst contenders, it’s possible you’ll be shocked to search out two-time batting champion and three-time All-Star Trea Turner right here attributable to his collapse on either side of the ball. The 33-year-old shortstop has alternated barely below-average months with some even worse ones (together with a 62 wRC+ in July). He’s hitting .236/.284/.355 on the season, and his 74 wRC+ is the ninth-lowest mark amongst qualifiers in each leagues, although he has firm inside at the moment’s installment. His 35.4% chase fee is a profession excessive, up 4.3 proportion factors from final season, whereas his 11.8% pulled-air fee is a profession low, down 4.1 factors from final 12 months and 6.1 factors from 2024. He’s been getting eaten alive by sliders, sweepers, and changeups, with batting averages under .200, slugging percentages under .260, and whiff charges above 38% in opposition to all three pitch varieties. On the defensive aspect, he ranks final on the place with -9 DRS whereas being tied for fourth worst with -6 FRV.

Turner’s uncharacteristically dangerous efficiency raises the chance that he’s enjoying via an harm, however at finest there are solely obscure hints. He left video games on June 15 and 18 after being hit by pitches, sustaining a proper wrist contusion from the previous and sitting out a recreation, then struggling and a proper calf contusion from the latter. Neither of these explains his season-long woes, however when interim supervisor Don Mattingly gave him a time off on July 8, he described Turner as “somewhat banged up, decrease half.” Turner is signed via the 2033 season, so he’s not going wherever besides perhaps to second base, a place the place he dabbled for stretches with the Nationals and Dodgers. Below that state of affairs, the Phillies must determine to commerce Bryson Stott, one thing I haven’t seen anybody recommend is an actual risk at this juncture. As the remainder of this collection will reveal, they produce other issues which are extra simply addressed.

Twins

With pending free brokers akin to Ryan Jeffers and Joe Ryan (who has a mutual choice that he’ll possible decline), the Twins have typically been categorised as possible deadline sellers relatively than contenders, however at 48-49, they’re tied for the third AL Wild Card spot, with 34.5% Playoff Odds. In the event that they’re seeking to contend, upgrading at shortstop ought to be on the agenda. The staff started the season with Brooks Lee because the starter, however he struggled each offensively and defensively earlier than shifting to 3rd base — the place he’s achieved a a lot better job — in late Might. That would put Royce Lewis, who has began to recuperate his stroke whereas enjoying first base, into play as someone else’s change-of-scenery candidate at third.

Since Lee’s transfer, Tristan Grey and Ryan Kreidler have shared shortstop duties whereas getting probably the most publicity of their transient main league careers. Grey, a lefty-swinging 30-year-old utilityman, isn’t solely batting simply .235/.274/.337 (68 wRC+), however can also be seven runs under common in line with each DRS and FRV. Kreidler, a righty-swinging 28-year-old who has largely break up his time between shortstop and heart discipline, is hitting a more healthy .248/.317/.426 (107 wRC+) general, with a 144 wRC+ in 68 plate appearances whereas overlaying shortstop. Whereas he deserves an extended have a look at one place or one other (he’s additionally noticed at third and in left), a contention-minded Twins staff ought to lift the ground right here in case the league catches up.

Brewers

Shifting Joey Ortiz from third base to shortstop landed the Brewers on this listing final 12 months, and on the offensive aspect, issues haven’t improved. His present 68 wRC+ (.225/.291/.305) is only a level greater than it was final season. Now each he and David Hamilton, with whom he shared time at shortstop, are overlaying third base as a result of in mid-June, the staff promoted 21-year-old Cooper Pratt, its sixth-round pick of a Mississippi highschool in 2023, after simply 58 video games at Triple-A Nashville. Such is the Brewers’ religion in Pratt that they signed him to an eight-year, $50.75 million extension in late March.

Although he made different retailers’ High 100 Prospects lists, Pratt missed that of FanGraphs, grading out as a 45-FV prospect right here, as a strong defender at shortstop with above-average contact capacity however much less energy than his 6-foot-4, 210-pound body suggests. To this point, he’s been a considerable improve, hitting .257/.360/.324 (97 wRC+) with 4 DRS and 1 FRV in 24 video games. Given the Brewers’ long-term funding, I’d anticipate they’ll stick to him relatively than search an improve from exterior.

Rays

Taylor Partitions is an distinctive fielder and an exceptionally dangerous hitter. He’s put up 65 DRS in simply 425 video games at shortstop for the reason that begin of 2021 (tops by 26 runs in that span) however only a 70 wRC+ in 1,827 plate appearances (the majors’ third-worst mark amongst gamers with a minimum of 1,500 plate appearances). This 12 months has been extra of the identical. His 13 DRS leads all shortstops by 5 runs, although he has -1 FRV (he’s been barely under common by that metric over the 2021–26 span), and in the meantime, he’s hitting simply .213/.310/.280 (70 wRC+), a mix that has netted him a modest 0.4 WAR. Sturdy hitting by Ben Williamson (157 wRC+ and 0.6 WAR in simply 53 plate appearances) in spot obligation has outdone that, but it surely’s been offset nearly fully by the struggles of Carson Williams and Oliver Dunn in even smaller slices of enjoying time.

The 23-year-old Williams is a legit prospect, a 2021 first-round decide who positioned twenty eighth on our High 100 listing as a 55-FV prospect within the spring however has since been downgraded to a 50 FV (no. 101 on The Board). He profiles as a Gold Glove-caliber defender with good uncooked energy however vital contact points; he’s struck out in 33% of his 762 plate appearances at Triple-A for the reason that begin of 2023 and at a 39.6% clip in 139 main league plate appearances in 2025–26. When Partitions and Williamson had been every sidelined briefly attributable to accidents, Williams spent two stretches with the Rays this 12 months, however hit simply .100/.156/.133 in 33 plate appearances — not a terrific commercial for extra enjoying time, however the staff figures to check him once more in some unspecified time in the future.

Marlins

With a significant league-best 26-11 document for the reason that begin of June, the Marlins at the moment are seven video games above .500 (52-45) and sitting within the third NL Wild Card spot. Nonetheless, third base is a hassle spot for them, because the 55 wRC+ produced by Javier Sanoja, Graham Pauley, Leo Jiménez, and Connor Norby is decrease than that of every other contender at any non-catcher place. Sanoja has gotten probably the most time there with 45 begins, along with two begins at second and 10 unfold throughout all three outfield spots. General, he’s hitting a strong .272/.313/.404 (95 wRC+) whereas placing out simply 8.6% of the time, much less typically than any participant with a minimum of 200 plate appearances moreover Luis Arraez and Nico Hoerner, however in his time at third base, he’s managed only a 75 wRC+ in 181 plate appearances. Recently he’s been sharing the job with Jiménez, who has hit .215/.309/.308 (75 wRC+) general, albeit with only a 50 wRC+ in 74 plate appearances whereas enjoying third. Norby and Pauley have been even much less productive whereas manning the recent nook; each had been optioned to Triple-A Jacksonville late final month.

The 4 aforementioned gamers are all pretty younger — Norby is 26, Sanoja 23, and the opposite two 25 — and as prospects graded out as both 40-FV or 45-FV varieties, with some worth as position gamers. With higher luck, the Marlins may cobble collectively an honest timeshare (although solely Pauley swings from the left aspect), however as that hasn’t occurred, they want actual assist. The Twins’ Lewis may present an actual improve right here.

Mariners

With Eugenio Suárez departing by way of free company, the Mariners traded for the versatile Brendan Donovan in early February, planning for him to man third base, and when he’s been accessible, he’s hit a sturdy .274/.386/.452 (145 wRC+) with three residence runs. Nevertheless, he’s struggled defensively in what little time he’s spent there (-2 DRS and -4 FRV in 191 2/3 innings) between journeys to the injured listing for groin strains in mid-April and mid-Might. In his absence, the staff has began eight different gamers at third, with Leo Rivas, J.P. Crawford, and Colt Emerson accounting for 15 to 22 begins apiece between them. Rivas hit a godawful .131/.263/.172 (39 wRC+) in 120 plate appearances — a efficiency that helped drag the Mariners into Killers territory — however is now again in Triple-A, whereas Crawford has shifted over from shortstop to accommodate the arrival of Emerson, a 20-year-old, 55-FV prospect whom the staff signed to an eight-year, $95 million extension simply after Opening Day. Crawford has hit .218/.334/.359 (107 wRC+) and performed a lot better protection at third base than at shortstop, whereas Emerson has tried to search out his footing. The rookie’s 92 wRC+ is respectable, even when his .201/.275/.396 line itself is relatively ugly, notably given a 34.4% strikeout fee and a 10-for-65 stoop since June 17.

The hope was that Donovan would start a rehab task within the Arizona Complicated League in the course of the All-Star break, however thus far, that hasn’t occurred. Barring a setback, he ought to return in some unspecified time in the future this month, giving the Mariners some flexibility, notably in the event that they need to give Emerson a Triple-A reset. If the rookie comes round, which may put Crawford, a pending free agent, into play as a commerce candidate at both quick or third.

Cardinals

In an effort to maintain the variety of gamers named Nolan of their lineup fixed, after buying and selling Nolan Arenado to the Diamondbacks in January, the Cardinals started the season with Nolan Gorman sharing time at third base with Ramón Urías. It didn’t go effectively; Gorman hit simply .194/.279/.318 with seven homers, a 32.3% strikeout fee, and -0.3 WAR earlier than being optioned in mid-June, first to spend nearly two weeks at their spring coaching advanced in Jupiter, Florida remodeling his swing. Issues haven’t clicked. He’s hit .121/.311/.293 with a 41.9% strikeout fee in 74 plate appearances at Triple-A Memphis. Urías didn’t hit a lick for St. Louis earlier than touchdown on the IL with a bout of tennis elbow on the identical day Gorman was despatched down. Since their departures, the staff has gone with Blaze Jordan, a 23-year-old, 40-FV rookie, and José Fermín, a 27-year-old veteran utilityman. The previous has hit simply .237/.253/.355 (62 wRC+), the latter a decent .259/.310/.392 (96 wRC+) — although he’s effectively forward of his anticipated stats. At 50-45 and one recreation out of a Wild Card spot, it is a staff that entered the season as presumptive sellers however should now reckon with its alternative to snag a playoff spot. Nonetheless, I’d anticipate a conservative method because the Cardinals proceed to cycle via inside choices.

Phillies

In contrast to Turner, Alec Bohm is an everyday at RLK Central, having made these lists in 2022 and ’23 and drawing point out in passing final 12 months. This 12 months, he’s returned on his personal deserves, hitting simply .215/.278/.354 (73 wRC+, seventh lowest amongst qualifiers in both league) and slipping again into true legal responsibility territory defensively (-6 DRS, -5 FRV) after years of battling the place to a bloody draw. His efficiency in opposition to breaking pitches has eroded, from a .308 common and .521 slugging in opposition to them in 2024, to a .272 common and a .370 slugging final 12 months, and now to .154 and .242. In the meantime, his efficiency in opposition to four-seamers has collapsed from a .322 common and a .409 slugging final season to respective marks of .196 and .351 this 12 months.

Bohm is a pending free agent, making this an space that Dombrowski can extra simply handle because the deadline approaches. Given the dearth of higher-end choices — the Giants’ Matt Chapman doesn’t appear prone to waive his no-trade clause — Bohm could also be a change-of-scenery candidate for one more staff right here.

Braves

From 2021–23, Austin Riley totaled extra residence runs (108) than every other third baseman and extra WAR (17.0) than all however one, future Corridor of Famer José Ramírez. Because the begin of 2024, nevertheless, Riley’s manufacturing has gone downhill, and whereas he hasn’t missed time this season attributable to accidents, as in 2024 (a fractured proper hand) or ’25 (a recurrent indirect pressure), his .207/.288/.329 (73 wRC+) hardly hints at what a power he was once. His 32.4% chase fee is his highest since 2020, whereas his 29.4% strikeout fee is his highest since ’19, his rookie season. He’s within the midst of his third straight season with a slugging proportion of .362 or decrease in opposition to four-seamers; he’s at present hitting .211 and slugging .321 in opposition to them with a 33.5% whiff fee. That is perhaps manageable if he weren’t hitting .190 and slugging .257 with a 36.5% whiff fee in opposition to breaking balls or hitting .159 and slugging .227 with a 40% whiff fee in opposition to offspeed pitches. Yikes. All of that’s notably ominous provided that Riley is the staff’s highest-paid participant, signed via 2032, but it surely possible means the Braves will maintain hoping he can hit his means out of his present miseries.

Yankees

In late July of final season, the Yankees cobbled collectively a 3rd base platoon of Ryan McMahon and Amed Rosario from a pair of trades. Even with the latter restricted by a shoulder harm, the strikes allowed them to shift Jazz Chisholm Jr. again to second base and offered a considerable improve to their protection, if not their offense. A 12 months later, the third base tandem isn’t working so effectively. McMahon is hitting simply .214/.277/.379 (83 wRC+) with average-ish protection, Rosario .238/.285/.457 (102 wRC+) with dreadful protection (-4 DRS, -6 FRV in simply 226 innings). If the Yankees had Aaron Choose and Giancarlo Stanton raking as they did final 12 months, they might in all probability keep the established order, however each sluggers are on the IL and a minimum of a number of weeks away from returning. The staff has made no secret of its need to improve its catching, however touchdown a greater third baseman who can present some offense must be a precedence, too.