The Blue Jays are inserting catcher Alejandro Kirk on the 10-day injured record with a left thumb fracture, based on Mitch Bannon of The Athletic. Catching prospect Brandon Valenzuela is being recalled from Triple-A in a corresponding transfer, per Hazel Mae of MLB Worldwide. Keegan Matheson of MLB.com was first to report that Valenzuela is within the Blue Jays’ clubhouse this morning.
Kirk exited final night time’s recreation towards the White Sox within the tenth inning after taking an Austin Hays foul tip off his thumb. Tyler Heineman took over behind the plate, and Kirk was promptly despatched for X-rays. Though the outcomes weren’t identified till this morning, some type of IL placement was anticipated for Kirk. In the long run, the X-rays revealed the fracture in addition to a dislocation, based on Ben Nicholson-Smith of Sportsnet. Kirk will meet with a specialist on Monday to find out whether or not surgical procedure is important. Primarily based on comparable accidents, the Jays can anticipate to lose Kirk for at the least six to eight weeks if he undergoes surgical procedure.
Any prolonged absence can be a blow to the Jays as they appear to make one other deep postseason run. The group is presently 4-3 and in second place within the AL East, though they’ve been outscored by their opponents 33-31. As well as, Kirk is arguably the group’s second-most useful participant behind Vladimir Guerrero Jr. After below-average offensive seasons in 2023-24, he rebounded final 12 months to publish a 116 wRC+ together with profession highs in house runs (15) and runs batted in (76). The 116 wRC+ was extra in step with his 110 profession wRC+ and makes him properly above common for a catcher. Certainly, Kirk’s 4.7 fWAR was second solely to AL MVP runner-up Cal Raleigh at that place.
Nearly as good as his offense is, Kirk can be an otherworldly defender. He was value 9 Defensive Runs Saved in 2025, which tied for third amongst certified catchers behind the Giants’ Patrick Bailey and the Crimson Sox’ Carlos Narváez. In line with Statcast, he graded out within the a hundredth percentile in blocks above common (21) and within the 98th percentile for framing. Whereas his caught stealing and pop time are nearer to common, these are very minor factors in what’s in any other case an impressive defensive profile. Altogether, Kirk was the second most-valuable defensive catcher within the majors final 12 months, primarily based on Statcast’s Fielding Run Worth metric.
Additional updates will come after Monday’s go to with the specialist. Clearly, the membership will hope that surgical procedure just isn’t wanted and that Kirk’s absence might be saved to a minimal. Within the meantime, Toronto will depend on Heineman and Valenzuela behind the plate. Heineman is only a backup at this stage of his profession, however the membership might give him the lion’s share of begins within the brief time period. His offense final 12 months was surprisingly robust, with Heineman posting a 120 wRC+ in 174 plate appearances. That was far off from his profession norms and partly the product of excellent luck, as evidenced by his .342 batting common on balls in play. Alternatively, Heineman accrued 10 DRS behind the plate, and he ranked within the eightieth percentile or higher for blocks, caught stealing, and framing. Thus, even when his offense regresses, his protection ought to assist him out as a brief beginning catcher.
As for Valenzuela, the 25-year-old was acquired in a commerce with the Padres final July and is one among Toronto’s prime 30 prospects based on MLB.com. The group added him to the 40-man roster in November. Supervisor John Schneider stated yesterday that Valenzuela can be known as up if Kirk wanted to overlook time. That has now come to move, and Valenzuela will get his first style of the large leagues.
Valenzuela participated in major-league Spring Coaching this 12 months and carried out admirably, batting .304/.370/.478 with a house run and three runs scored in 27 plate appearances. He first reached Triple-A in 2024 with the Padres and returned to that degree following his commerce to the Blue Jays. Valenzuela was barely above common at Double-A, although his efficiency at Triple-A has not been fairly as robust. That’s largely on account of contact points. In 105 PA with Toronto’s prime affiliate final 12 months, he struck out at a 30.5% clip and graded out 23% worse than common by wRC+. He has proven some enchancment early in 2026, slicing his strikeout price to 17.6%. Nonetheless, his offense hasn’t been his robust swimsuit on the prime degree of the minors.
Quite, Valenzuela’s worth comes from his work behind the plate. His MLB.com scouting report provides him well-above-average arm power and management of the operating recreation. He has a 33.8% caught-stealing price for the reason that begin of 2024, together with a 35.7% price at Triple-A, and he’s additionally famous for his potential to work with a pitching employees. His offense might maintain him from being a big-league beginning catcher, however his glovework provides him a good ceiling as a backup. For now, Heineman’s stronger latest offense in all probability provides him the beginning job. Valenzuela has three possibility years remaining and will simply return to Triple-A when Kirk ultimately returns.
Photograph courtesy of Kevin Sousa, Imagn Photos
